Attaching to God: Neuroscience-informed Spiritual Formation
Attaching to God connects relational neuroscience and attachment theory to our life of faith so you can grow into spiritual and relational maturity. Co-host Geoff Holsclaw (PhD, pastor, and professor) and Cyd Holsclaw (PCC, spiritual director, and integrative coach) talk with practitioners, therapists, theologians, and researchers on learning to live with ourselves, others, and God. Get everything in your inbox or on the app: https://www.grassrootschristianity.org/s/embodied-faith
Attaching to God: Neuroscience-informed Spiritual Formation
(Cross Post) The Head-Heart Disconnect: Cultivating a Deeper Relationship with God (with Colleen Ramser)
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This episode is cross-posted from Here, Not There, by Colleen Ramser, where she turns the tables and interviews me about the work we do and the upcoming Attaching to God Summit, focused on Deepening Relationships. Below are Colleen's show notes.
What if the gap between what you believe about God (head) and what you feel (heart) has something to do with the way your brain learned to protect you? Geoff Holsclaw explores how attachment theory, relational neuroscience, and theology can deepen our relationship with God and change the way we read Scripture, experience prayer, and understand God’s presence. Together, Colleen and Geoff discuss how attachment patterns can shape faith and relationships—and why knowing that God is loving doesn’t always mean we feel close, safe, or seen. Their conversation offers a thoughtful, hopeful look at moving beyond spiritual clichés toward a more embodied and relational faith.
This episode also highlights the Attaching to God summit this fall, October 13-15 (free!), where you can dive deeper into what it looks like to deepen your relationship with God, self, and others. Colleen will be featured talking about restoring wholeness after spiritual abuse.
Dive deeper in our new book, Landscapes of the Soul: How the Science and Spirituality of Attachment Can Move You into Confident Faith, Courage, and Connection, and learn about our trainings and other resources at embodiedfaith.life.
Stay Connected:
- The FREE Attaching to God Summit is happening (Oct. 13-15).
- Check out our Attaching to God 6-Week Learning Cohort.
- Join the Embodied Faith community to stay connected and get posts, episodes, & resources.
- Support our ministry with a one-time or regular gift.
Colleen Ramser
Hi there, Colleen here on the Here, Not There podcast finding our way back to presence, connection, and delight.
Hi there, friends. This is Colleen, your host, and I have a special guest with me that I'm really excited to bring to you all. You may have heard of him, but, if not, I think he has, him and his wife, just a wonderful body of information and discussions around God, deeper relationships, attachment. So today I have Geoff Holsclaw with me, and he is an author of multiple books, is a visiting professor of theology at Western Theological Seminary, and I actually almost took one of your cohorts.
Almost. I almost joined our good friend Dr. Pennington. I almost went with him. But so you do some cohort, you're finishing up some cohorts there, and you're the co-founder of the Center for Embodied Faith, and co-author of the Landscapes of the Soul: How the Science and Spirituality of Attachment Can Move You into Confident Faith, Courage, and Connection.
But you're also newly going to be the professor of theology starting next July at Northern Seminary. Yes. And you're gonna be teaching a cohort. What's the title of it? So yeah, we'll be starting a doctoral cohort, which will be on spiritual formation and relational neuroscience- Yes ... especially around attachment theory.
And it just looks so rich and really interesting- Yeah ... and layered and complex and dynamic, so I was really excited to see that and hear that. Yeah. Yeah, so- it's our third cohort. It's really resonated with people we're pulling together another one, I love the combination. But your cohort's gonna be amazing at Western also.
Yes. I love Travis. He's delightful. That's a great word to describe him. He's delightful. So I, we've talked here and there along the way. We have the same book agent, as well as I'm speaking at the summit this fall. But I actually w- I actually have a very selfish question that I just don't know about you, is just how you got into all of this.
Like, how did you get into attachment as a theology professor? Like, how did those worlds collide for you? Yeah. So it came out of kind of- our marriage. But really my wife Cyd, her dealing with some childhood trauma, ... that she had gone through. Her father was killed in a car accident when she- was 18 months old. And then she had a really rough time with her new father her stepfather, and just all sorts of things. And so when we got married, and then especially when we started having kids, she... Right when our first son got to about 18 months old, and she- was like, saw f- like, up close, like how much he interacts with the world- ... and how much he understood, then she went back to "Oh," "That was me- ... in a car- Wow ... when my dad died." And that started unlocking some things for her, and just being like I think I need to start taking some of this tr- trauma seriously and doing some of this work," 'cause she'd been doing that for a while.
But it kinda led us on this path to like the relational neuroscience and how just understanding how the brain works. Not just with trauma, but just in relationships as we move through, like connection and protection. And just just kinda having our eyes open to that. Yeah. And then coming across Jim Wilder's work and his definition of joy.
Love it. And- Yes ... yeah. So s- the idea that joy is being with somebody who is glad to be with you back. And so we started learning these things, and then we're both pastoring, so we're bringing some things like gratitude and other just practices into the local church. But I was also a theology professor at the time.
I got my PhD at Marquette in Milwaukee s- in systematic theology. So I'm teaching theology and I'm like, this whole idea of God with us or- ... God wanting to be with us, this is like the whole story of the Bible. But why don't we teach theology from that center of God wants to be with you?"
Yes. And so I started just teaching my systematic theology classes and reorganizing all the content. And that's where our first book came out of, which is called Does God Really Like Me? It kinda just took all of that material as... It's, I call it like a sneaky, sneaky biblical theology of God's presence.
God- I love it ... God does want to be with you, so God does like you- He does like you ... is the short answer. Yeah. And then it just kinda kept going from there. I'm a nerd. I'm a research nerd, so then I kinda fell into the brain science stuff, and especially attachment therapy, or theory. Yeah
not therapy. I'm not a therapist. A theologian. Yeah, and there was a time... I tell people I just bought all these books, Allan Schore, Dan Siegel, Yeah ... reading all the primary resources, and there was a time where I'm like, I just was praying. I was like, "Jesus, why am I reading all this stuff?"
"This has no application to my life and ministry." There is no theology. Yeah. And then, but then, like, all of a sudden, I was like, actually, this has so much to do with discipleship and pastoral work and and the sense that especially attachment theory had not really been, like, embraced or utilized in- yeah
the church or discipleship at all. And I was like, okay, this is really important. So that's kinda- Yeah ... how I got into it. I g- you know, it's interesting 'cause the theology mixed with this attachment relational kinda neuroscience way of being, was there a moment for you where... theology just seems so heady, right?
Yeah. Where it felt like your worlds were integrating in terms of head and heart, ... and all of these concepts and ideas? It was s- it was like slow-moving, Yeah, for sure ... in one sense. So a year ago, we launched the Center for Embodied Faith. So that's kinda where all of our work has started.
But that was- ... really one aspect in, in kind of this larger work. In my s- like systematic theology, I was "Hey," "in discipleship, we really need to m- move from like a disembodied mind- ... to an embodied faith." It's ... And then that term, I was like, that's actually I think that's kinda getting at a lot of what our work is.
And so the m- the more kind of attachment theory, how children develop relationships- ... with their parents, how that kinda shapes their body and their brain and their nervous system, how kind of the larger relational neuroscience, social referencing, polyvagal theory, like all these different things- ... it just really helped me read the Bible better. ... And the more that people have gone through some of our trainings or read some of our books, they're just, they also say the same thing. They're like, "Oh, I can read the Bible better." So- ... I think that integration it's still like ongoing.
Every time I read, reread it, some, Scripture, I'm like, "Oh, that's," "this makes so much sense now that we know." Yeah. So- Yeah ... I always kinda think that and a lot of people have said this, that like the science is actually catching up with Scripture- Yeah ... as far as how we're made and but it's, for me, it's ongoing.
Yeah, so the head and the heart and how it all comes together, it's still ongoing, oh, I wanna go back to what you said about the Bible and reading it, and- Okay ... that people are able to read it better. What does that look like? Yeah. What does re- I'm assuming a lot of the attachment and a l- deep, just a deeper relationship G- with God.
What does that look like reading the Bible from your perspective to read the Bible better or to feel a better sense when you read the Bible? So it really helps me read the Bible a lot more relationally and I guess a lot more embodied. And so you- ... see the cues for like people interacting. So even like the, the call to Moses, and God sending Moses back to Israel. And so when you study attachment and, and you hear words like attunement and these are ther- therapeutic words too, like being attuned and having a limited- Yeah ... resonate, resonance or whatever- yeah ... word you wanna put around it.
Resonate, res- resonance. But so you read Exodus and what does God say? He says, "I have seen my- ... people, I have heard their cries- ... and I have come down to deliver them." And so when you start thinking through like a parent-child relationship- Yeah ... you're like that's an attuned parent- Yes ... who is acting on behalf of a distressed child.
Like- ... he saw that they are in distress, he heard that they are in distress, and he has come down to do something about it. And so- Yeah ... it's just like all those relational kind of layers really start just like popping out. The same would be for the and we talk about this quite a bit in our book, but the the blessing that God gave Moses he told Moses, but Aaron was supposed to bless the people.
And how it speaks of God's face two different times, that God's- ... face would shine upon his people and be gracious- ... upon them, and God would turn his face toward them and bring them peace. And when you understand kind of the, not just attachment, but just like the neuroscience of how faces and non-verbals- Yes
Are communicated it's just wow. And then at the very end it says, "And this is how you will put my name upon the people." And so- ... those are also very embodied and relational. So it's like the, the face-to-face aspect, it's the name, which is the family. So this is like how like you'll bring the Israelites into my family, is by giving them this blessing, which speaks of the face of God multiple times.
So those would just be like two different examples. Yeah. I love that because I do think that there is such a danger in theology not being relational or scripture not being relational, which leads to all kinds of havoc, ... and fundamentalism and lots of things, within the church. So what do you think is happening underneath the surface when someone genuinely loves God but still struggles to experience God as close, safe or available?
I know. It's a big- So yeah, that's a really good question. Bam. That's really good. There you go. Have fun. We'll have fun. So I would say it's two parts. So the, the keywords would be compensating and corresponding. So these are- ... com- coming from the attachment literature. And the first one is that, sometimes, or oftentimes, we come to have a relationship with God because it's compensating for a lack, for something that we don't have in our life.
This is the- ... whole God-shaped hole in our lives. And the idea is if didn't get this from your family, or if you didn't get a certain, kind of love and acceptance or or even s- for some people it's actually a calling and purpose. If you didn't- get that, then you feel like that something's missing, and then you're looking for it, and then God kinda steps in and fills that in, right? So the, the attachment literature would say God, in a sense, is compensating. It's filling in for that lack, and that's a good thing. But they will also say there's the sense in which our attachment kind of styles, or we like to say strategies 'cause they come out of the environment you were raised in.
It's just like- ... they're not personalities or something like that. It's a- They're protective ... just an adaptive ... Yes. Yes, adaptive ... an adaptive, protective- Yeah ... strategy. And so your attachment strategy is deeply embedded in you. It's not something you're thinking about. It's just something you act from- Right
right, all these implicit layers. And so what the research would also say is on your conscious level you could say God is compensating for something, and I love God in the way in which He's, helped me filled out what was lacking," and that's really important. And it, you had, maybe you had a very monumentous kinda shift in your life in which- that happened, and that's all really good. But then the research will say but there's these deeper kind of attachment filters or strategies Todd Hall calls them filters we call them defaults that you live out of. ... And more often than not- Your deep-seated attachment strategy is not changed when you're converted all of a sudden.
That, that deep kind of relational structure, your relational habits, doesn't change all of a sudden. Some of them might. Maybe one or two of them. Sure. And so you have these deep patterns and oftentimes you interact with God as if God was one of those insecure attachment figures that you had.
Yeah. And so on one hand, you're more- So it's a projection, right? Yeah. Yeah. So yeah, using that language- Yes ... it's a projection. Yeah. You project God to be a certain way based off of what you're used to, based off of- ... what you got from your kind of key attachment relationships. And so I think that's where a lot of the head/heart kinda stuff happens, is in my head I know that God loves me and that he died for me- he sent his son and that I'm forgiven and I can rely on God's truth, and God's always present 'cause God is everywhere. God is in my heart, the Holy Spirit, right? You have all these- ... truths in your head that you're conscious of, but your kind of spontaneous reactions go a totally different way, which is- Right
well, actually, God can't be trusted because my attach- my, my, attachment figures couldn't really be trusted to be reliable. Sometimes they were there, sometimes they weren't. Yes. Or they only showed up to criticize me, and so I often assume that God's just showing up to criticize me, and when God comes near, it's to point out what all I'm doing wrong, right?
So we have all these things. And so that's where I think after a while people really get stuck, so some people call it, like, hitting the wall spiritually. There's all sorts of nuanced things. Would you say it's just like a dark night? Like this is- yeah ... kinda the large dark night?
Theologians have different ways to talk about it. Yeah. But- Yeah ... but that's where I think God, then God says, "Okay let's start rooting out these really deep-seated patterns and beliefs that you have of the world." That's gonna be a much more painful and difficult process. Yeah. I just thought of a, a, kind of another tough question.
Yeah. It's just coming to me, sorry. 'Cause I have studied a lot about dark nights and been through it myself. Would you say that it's scriptural or even, like what's your take on God's presence, like God removing his presence from someone? Is that possible? And is it when you're in a dark night, it's really you've disconnected and disassociated, whether im- imposed or, due to the circumstances, it's so cloudy it's hard to experience God's presence?
Oh, that is a tough one. I know. This is a tough one, I know. I think you probably have more insight than I do. I just, we can just hash it out. I, I'm ver- genuinely curious even if we don't have an answer. But I've- Yeah ... wondered this. I'd like to think God is with us and that is legit all the way through, but are there times when God is just far for various reasons?
Yeah. Well- I th... Yeah, for various reasons. We can just- that's a key- ... edit that it- That's a key word, right? ... just needed. That's, yeah. No. I'm a firm believer in no editing. Let's just- Yeah. We'll try to hash it out. I think what the various reasons, one, this, the this is a podcast.
We're both on Instagram. Like we are, and we live in- Yes ... a soundbite world, right? Yeah. I think this is one of those things that really resists soundbites. And really- It does ... I think it calls for... And this is what we've lost, and this is why it's such a hard question- ... is it really calls- Yeah
for spiritual friendships- ... and spir- even spiritual mentoring. Just people to walk with to then have regular conversations about this. It's not like- Yeah ... oh, I... Because everyone's so different. Every every situation is different. What looks like a dark night of the soul for someone might just be a trauma response that, you know- Yeah, exactly
needs to be healed in someone else. Yeah. And it could just be sinful rebellion, or- ... yes. And it's, it's- ... it's hard to know- ... what it is. But big picture so in our work we use the language of meeting and moving. I like that. Is that God meets us- Yeah
where we are, but then is longing to move us deeper into the pastures of Psalm 23, like the fullness- ... of life in John 10:10. So God meets us where we are, and sometimes that even means being somewhat misrecognized or even used. God is useful for us where we are in our insecure- Yeah
attachment or in our trauma or just wherever. But then God wants to lead us deeper into His love, and there is a sense in which we need to move out of God being useful for us to just we love God just because. Yeah. And so I think historically the dark night of the soul is part of that transition.
It's the wilderness that moves God from being like I get things out of God. I feel- the genie. Yeah. It's a genie. I feel good. God leads me. I had... Just to be really personal, I was- Sure ... discerning a really big decision just this year, s- so we'll just say a couple months ago from whenever this podcast comes out.
And i- and in the past, I'd been, like very diligent in discerning my life, our life. We had a giant pastoral move. We moved our whole family ac- different states, entered a new church. And the Lord really clearly led us. This is 10 years ago. And so in this new discernment time, I was expecting something different, or the same.
I was expecting the same thing. Same. "Lord, I will pray." Same type of way. "I will you will lead, and I will follow. I will obey. I am yours. I'm happy to... just show me. Show me what to do." Yeah. "I submit." Yeah. And, and that was true, and that was heartfelt. But the response I got back from Jesus this time was like Was it was like- "oh, you'll figure it out." "And I just want you to know that I love you." Like it was, I, it was kinda like I told someone, I was like, I got, I felt like I got Jesus juked by Jesus. Yeah. Because He was like- Oh my gosh ... I just want you to be close to my heart." Th- those were actually the words that I got, was like- "i just want you to be close to my heart." I literally in my spirit then rolled my eyes. I was like, "Whatever, Jesus. Just tell me which way to go." Oh, yes. Yeah. But I, like as a- So good ... and I was kinda mad. I was act- I was mad at Jesus, if you could, ... if you can allow for it. Oh, yeah.
I can be mad. And the Psalms get mad at Jes- at Jesus too- Yes ... if we could say it that way, just for the record. So it took me about a month of a little spiritual disorientation, a little being irritated, and "I just want you to lead me, Jesus. That's what you've always said," yeah. Like John 15, Or no, wait. Whatever. The Good Shepherd. One of those. No, that's John 14. Yes. John 14 is the good shepherd. He lets his- Yeah ... sheep out, and they know his name, and they follow his voice. I was like, "I'm just trying to be a good sheep, Jesus." And but it was later where I think I kinda got to the space of like Jesus was like, "Yeah, the f- the following thing is great and you're doing that fine- but like just being with me is what I really want." Yeah. So- That's good ... I don't think that's the same thing as The Dark Night, but I think they're like, they're these other similar streams- Yes ... of how do we kinda shift out of that I don't love a real strong like being and doing sh- Oh, for sure
dichotomy, but I think- yes ... I think that kinda being with Jesus was kind of the shift. I really love that whole story because it, it makes me think too about, I think it's Dallas Willard who says, "God will guide us but not override us." And so often, sometimes- Ooh, I like that one ... we can be- I'm gonna steal that.
Yes, it's really good. It's in my book, so if you just do a little search, it's in there. Okay, good. 'Cause I loved it because I think it really speaks to the sense of, yes, God guides us and we follow. And s- and in some instances, God is like, "Do this here," and he's very specific. But a lot of times, I really think God's just "Here's a canvas.
Paint a landscape. Everybody gets this opportunity. Have fun. Just have fun." You don't need- Yeah ... you don't need to know where the blue goes and the, the brown and all the other colors. Just have fun, and as long as it's within these boundaries, you're good. But it makes me think of that story of how maybe sometimes we're searching for God so deeply.
"God, tell me what I need to do now," and every day and every minute, when we might interpret it as God's not with us, when He's really just trying... he's like the, the adult mom that's sitting on the couch watching her favorite show like, "You're good. Just go have fun." "Play at the, play on the monkey bars."
Yeah. Yeah. One thing that I w- I was also thinking about, especially, in relation to the theme of the summit this year, was deeper relationships with God- Yeah ... self, and others. And, it seems like makes sense based on the work that you and your wife do.
But what sort of stirred that theme for you with this, this year's summit? Yeah. This is the third year that we've done it. The first year we just kinda had a global, like attaching to God and just brought a lot of different people to talk about it. The second year we talked about cultivating intimacy and independence- as these two kind of sides of how we relate to other people and ourselves and the world. And so this year I really just wanted to be more like practical. Like we just wanna give people tools and an understanding of how do we deepen our relationships. And so I, we just brought together lots of people with lots of different expertise and and it's really fun because people have some are therapists, some are pastors- Yeah ... and we're just kinda bringing together a lot of helpful things. I feel like, and I've heard this and I'm sure the summit's not gonna hit the 20 and younger crowd so much.
But I think there is this like a, an understanding that, you know, the loneliness epidemic and I don't think that's just because of like technology or a- ... COVID hangover or social media I think those things are part of it. But I think, we have multiple generations of kind of eroded relational skills- and relational capacities. And so even the people who are- Yeah ... most desperate to be in a relationship, they actually don't have the skills- No ... the capacities, or kind of the, like deep wisdom and rule of thumb- Yeah ... that help you be in relationships. So you have this deep craving to be in relationships, but then like you get close and you know- Don't know what to do
everyone's just kinda... Yeah, you just don't know what to do. Yeah. I'm sure you run into that quite a bit, maybe the younger you the clients that you work with. Even personally, there's times I'm like, "I don't know what to do with you." So that's kinda like the heart of it, is just how can we just equip people, Yeah
on just all sorts of different ways to have deeper relationships with God, with themselves, and with other people. Yeah. Let me kinda just talk a little bit about the deeper relationship with others. I know we've got God and self. They all kinda interplay really. But I feel like I'm 44 years old, and I feel like in my 40s, I saw an interesting shift for people that, like if you were making new friends, it- it's real awkward.
Pe- you'd think that like people would grow into their 40s and have a better sense of like self, and that would- ... sorta translate into better connections, but it's almost like I saw the opposite. It was like in 20s, 30s, you're just connecting for all kinds of different reasons, going out, doing this, doing that.
I, I don't know. I'm curious to hear, like what does, like connecting, what do, what does connecting with others look like, and what are some of those barriers, whether it's attachment style and unpacking that, and if you've seen anything connected to people as they get older and how that's hindered.
Oh, this is- I know, right? ... like outside my areas of expertise. Ah, yeah. But I think our attachment kinda strategies affect us throughout our whole life un- until- ... or including when we really take them seriously and start trying to shift and pay attention and- ... so I don't know if there's like a...
our mutual friend, Jonathan Pennington, he's doing a lot of- Yeah ... like life stage research, so I'd be curious to ask him that question. Oh, yes. I wonder if in- I'll tell- yeah ... the f- if in your 40s and maybe 50s. I'm 48. Yeah. If there's kind of a, a resignation of "I don't know, this is just how I relate to people," you know- Yeah, maybe
just- Yes ... rather than, especially when you have younger kids or you're newly married- ... you're "Hey, we're all in this together." - Yeah. Yeah ... "We just gotta get along." Yeah. "There's sports teams. We're going to school." Yes. And then when you get to... I don't know how old your kids are but I'm an empty nester.
Yes. And so now it's kinda maybe it's just this is who I am, and these are the people I like to be with, and I actually get to choose now," yeah. Which is not great, right? The church, the s- Sure ... e- ecclesial body of church is actually supposed to help work against those inclinations of just kinda getting stuck in an age group or stuck in your own relational ruts.
Yeah. Yeah. So I wouldn't say- how- ... those are good habits, but if I were- Oh, for sure ... to look at my own life- Yeah. Yeah ... that's somewhat happened. How about someone who does get stuck in a... Maybe they, they're just not growing in their attachment strategy, per se, to better connection.
Yeah. And I think of the person who tends to be, like, a little bit more avoidant or maybe they're flaky socially. They're like, "Oh yeah, let's hang out. No, just kidding. Never mind." But then they they'll say nobody ever wants to hang out with me. I don't wanna... I feel so alone."
And you're like- ... "Just hang out." What do you see there? What are... May- maybe even from some of the speakers that you spoke to, something that arose or that you see that's this breakdown there of this avoidance or avoidance of intimacy, really. I mean- Yeah. Yeah ... I think that's what's happening there.
So for someone who's yeah, in the, we call that the desert, living in the desert- ... of relationships- ... of social, emotional kind of connection and... but then also with themselves. There's a desert within themselves. They don't really understand their s- emotions and their connections as much.
I think the f- wherever you're at and I got this especially from Cyd, is just cultivating self-compassion and awareness. Yeah. Yeah. "Oh, what are my habits?" ... You can't always figure out and tell a story about where they all came from, Sure ... but just understanding where you are, like, "Yeah, I do tend to rather to be alone, and I do tend to- not process my emotions, at least with other people. I do tend to prefer solving problems rather than listening to people talk about their problems." Let's just fix it. I, you know- Yeah. ... I prefer... so there's certain tendencies of someone who's an avoidant attached. And so I think having compassion "Yeah, that is my knee-jerk reaction to life."
Yeah ... and s- so cultivating some compassion, but then trying to do some cross-training skills, try to develop things the other direction, like, So someone who's in the desert is probably r- on the whole these are generalizations- Sure. Sure, of course ... leans more toward the the logical, linear kind of view of the world, problem-solving.
This happened, then this happened, and, if you stop doing this, then this would stop happening. Right? Is you- ... kinda speak about the whole world that way. And cross-training to grow, so that would be, like, pressing into... And I'm speaking about myself. So I have full disclosure, like- For su- sure
I, I'm avoidant adjacent. I'm anxious avoidant. Oh, okay. There you go. That's why I go back in for it. I'm by myself now. I'm good. Yes. So I've had to cultivate, I started with just, how do I connect with my own emotions? How do I get better- ... at asking kind of emotional or relation kinda questions of my wife and my kids?
And how do I start developing, yeah, those, like, social, emotional kind of skills and capacities? Yeah ... but then also giving myself compassion yeah a certain kind of relational work that my wife does would totally exhaust me. I could never be a therapist. It would just exhaust me.
Yeah. Right? But the intellectual- Sure ... work that I like to do and the researching- Yes ... and then the teaching that actually energizes me, right? Yeah. And it's kinda the opposite for Cyd. And so I think spiritually, what does that mean? Something like maybe you love- Like studying the Bible, which is fine, which is great.
I love studying the Bible. Yeah. Yes. Like deep studying. I love theology, right? But then usually you're kinda staying in a certain bit of scripture, right? So could you start branching out? Could you start reading the Psalms and trying to figure out what all those emotions are doing? Or trying- The web of emotions in the Psalms.
Yeah. Or- ... as you read a Psalm, trying to imagine what it might feel like to say or express those things to God. ... And so trying to-- So you're still studying the Bible, but you're maybe studying something that's different as a way to kinda move yourself like out. Or when you're reading the Gospels, trying to think about like what was Jesus, what was his face like when he talked to that person?
Yeah. 'Cause we just have the letters- Yeah ... on the page, right? And some of them are read, right? Yeah. But if Jesus really is full of, truth and grace, if he actually loved people 'cause yeah- ... oftentimes, like I would read scripture, so I always tell this story but we would read scripture at our previous church.
We would read four scriptures. We're kinda the old liturgical. We'd do like an Old Testament- Oh, I like it ... a Psalm- Yeah ... a New Testament epistle, and then we'd end with a gospel. And there was this- Yeah And he read everything angry. No matter- Oh. ... like what the words were, it was always stern. Like- Oh, wow
it wasn't angry. So angry is too- No I get you ... but it was stern ... very stoic. It was like- Stoic. Yeah, stoic, stern- Yeah ... earnest. Everything was so earnest. Yes. And you're like, "Did Jesus really talk to the lepers that way?" I think he was... Did, did Zacchaeus come down from that tree because Jesus had a furrowed brow-
and was scolding him? Probably not. Yeah. Yeah. He was probably more welcoming. So I think for people in the desert, like cultivating that more generous kind of an abiding kind of way of experiencing- ... Scripture I think would be really important to start breaking down kinda some of those tendencies- Yeah
that we would have to make everything stern, and everything's- Yes ... logical, and everything has its place. So those are some of the things that came to mind. Yeah. It made me think about, you know how, I'm sure you've read this, where people, when they've gone through trauma or they've obviously had a bad experience relationally, they can misread faces.
Yeah. And so even, like a, just a neutral face can look angry or it can look mad when it's just somebody's kinda, as they are in a resting, resting face. Yes. It's their resting face. So it's just interesting- I- ... to think about, yeah, go on ... i, so some of the, so about the attachment stuff, 'cause that's what I know best, I think- that, I'd love to hear s- more about those faces too, but they would say, so people who are in the desert, they're more likely to look at the mouth when people are c- talking because- Oh my gosh ... their concern is- Interesting ... and it's more left brained technically too. Yeah. But they're concerned about the words, the, the logical link.
Oh. "I wanna know the words." Oh. And people who are more anxiously attached, what we call the jungle- Yeah ... they look at people's eyes more. So they've actually tracked this. That's fascinating. And and that makes sense because people who are more anxiously attached are- Yeah ... very much into the non-verbal communication and very much into the whole communication.
Yes ... which the eyes communicate. So you can actually tell if somebody's lying better through the eyes, not through the mouth. Wow. Wow. So people are like someone who's very attuned to relationships are looking at the eye, but someone who's in the desert, they just wanna know the words.
That's how I was. So tell me the words. Yeah. Get to the bottom line. Yeah. What are we talking about? Yeah. And I'm, so- What an interesting- ... my wife and I would have fights- Yeah ... because I would literally say things like, "This is the word I said to you, and then this is the word you said back to me-
and this is the exact order of the events that happened." And then she's like "I don't know, but your whole face says you're mad at me." And I was like- "I don't, I'm not mad." That's so good. And then I tell her, "I'm not mad at you because if I was mad at you, I would tell you that I'm mad at you," but I didn't say those words so- Oh
So anyway, that's a- What a fantastic description of that. And I notice, oh my gosh, I'm having this aha moment, I look at the eyes and the mouth, which is, which just makes sense then because I can- That's probably good. That's probably a more- I'm like- ... integrated way, right? I go back and forth and that's so fascinating.
But I didn't know that, so that's a great bit of information. We can leave the faces. All right. I don't think I've ever shared this. This is just a small little tidbit. But because I am more avoidant, like, when people when... Even in movies, when people- ... share a real intimate kinda thing, I, and I can't figure it- Maybe you know this.
Okay. Okay. If you can tell me why I do this. I'll try my best. I'll pull it out of my- I look away. It's this weird- ... I have this weird reflex that you know, when people- Ooh ... are very, like- Yeah ... intense, I- Yeah ... look away, and I wonder if it's a an ingrained capacity issue or if it's just like- It...
I'm sure. Yeah ... or if it's just- Something ... I always wanna hear, and if I'm, like, watching, I can't hear the words. It's this weird- ... I do the same thing, like listening to sermons. I do not watch- Yeah ... preachers. I kinda look away. Yeah. My eyes are wandering. Anyways, blah, blah, blah. Oh, I- I don't know if that's because of my attachment strategy or if it's just 'cause I'm ADHD- Yeah
or if I'm just weird. I don't know. My brain is actually kinda processing that, and I don't have any good literature for it, but my brain is thinking that ten- I would say a tendency for somebody who's avoidant is the best way that they're able to connect to themselves is by going inward for a second- and that it's too much to see all of that. It's just, it's the capacity just gets blown. So it's a... 'Cause I can relate in terms of being anxious avoidant that I, sometimes I just need to be with myself. I need to be by myself in order to digest whatever it is- ... that I'm trying to emotionally process.
So that would be my speculation is- Yeah ... is that- Yeah ... it's your way of titrating it to come to it. Yeah. Yeah. And I think and that's the advice I'd give to people is, like- Right ... do as much as you can, but, then take a break. Exactly, yeah. So how about connecting with God, there, a- and connecting to self?
We're kinda diving into that a little bit. What are some just interesting things that you've learned so far from some of the summit speakers? Or maybe something surprising where you're like, "Ooh, that's new. Never thought about that." I'm looking at the titles here. Yeah. No, go ahead.
I had ... So I had a really good c- ... And this kinda goes back to The Dark Night of the Soul, but Kyle Strobel he's a- Yeah ... a theologian, and h- I forget the name of his new book, so sorry, Kyle. That's okay ... but he has a whole section where he talks about, he uses kinda the older language of consolation and desolations.
And how God will kinda meet us with what he calls early consolations. ... As it goes to the Protestant kind of spiritual formation from a couple hundred years ago. Yeah. About how God meets us with these early consolations of Scripture, of just feeling God's love for me.
You know- Yeah ... this real kind of rich experience. But then those kinda fade, and it's not exactly the dark night, it can be disorienting. Yeah ... and so that was a really interesting kind of conversation just to keep thinking about these movements between early consolations, a time of desolation, and then later consolations.
Yeah. Yeah ... and I just feel like we don't really speak about the spiritual journey that way. We're a very access-oriented, on-demand kind of culture right now. So it's like, if I'm not feeling it, something's wrong. If something's wrong, something can be fixed, 'cause our culture fixes everything- Yes
'cause we have technology that makes everything work. So we kinda have this mentality, but this kind of like slower view of, yeah, sometimes God feels distant, and that's good- Yeah ... for you. And it's like, "What do you mean that's good for me? It feels- ... horrible." Yeah. So- ... so that was a really good, Yeah, I love that
Kinda, because sometimes- ... process ... I think do- people do kinda think, "Oh, there's something wrong with me spiritually. I don't feel God. I don't," "When I read Scripture, it feels dull." A- and sometimes it's just, it's just a season and it's where you're at, and it doesn't necessarily mean that your relationship with God has changed or there's something wrong with it.
Yeah. I thought Monica Maurer's she's a therapist. She works with Life Model for those w- who know Life Model's work with Jim Wilder. And she just kinda made this really clear statement. It's like, "Our brain is wired one way for all these relationships." And that was- like a really helpful... It's not like our brain works differently in relationship- ... to God than it does- Yeah ... with other people. Yeah ... like our mind and our spirit, like they're all for good and for bad. If I have a lot of- ... bad expectations and bad habits when it comes to relationships that are wired into my brain and nervous system- i'm not escaping that when I try to pray or when I go to worship. Like I'm- Yes ... I'm bringing that. Now, that doesn't mean- ... change isn't possible. It totally is possible. Sure. ... But that one wiring is the same for all of our relationships. It was such a simple kinda statement, but that was super helpful also.
Nice. Yeah. Those are some good ones. So when is the summit? Can, Oh ... I will probably air this, some- somewhat soon before the summit. And if you could tell us a little bit about it. And- Yeah ... I know you're gonna possibly air this on your podcast as well, so Yeah. It's October 13 through the 15th.
Each day there'll be five different, videos that will be released. The first day is like the biblical scholars and theologians. The second day is therapists and counselors. That's where you'll be. And then the third day is spiritual directors and pastors and spiritual formation leaders.
And each day, those are all free for 36 hours. You can just listen. It's not so much c- sometimes there's online summits where it's like you can get 50 videos, but you have to watch them in 24 hours. And it's like how do I even do that? Yeah. Excuse me. Yeah, that's basically it.
If you kinda register for free, you'll just kinda get it all in your inbox. You'll also get a bunch of free kinda goodies. You have something on offer, so if you register, then you get all that stuff for free. So what was yours, by the way? Just for everyone. I actually did a, It's a seven-day devotional based on the book- Right
my book, The Shattered Soul. So it was like a wet your whistle with the book. Yeah. Very digestible if you've been through spiritual abuse- Nice ... or spiritual trauma. Yeah. Yes. So that's all for free. So yeah, it's great. We had about 5,000 people sign up last year to participate virtually.
Then there's also a all-access pass if you want to kinda view it any time for years yeah ... on your own time then you can kinda purchase that and then have it. And then we're actually... This might be helpful for you and your audience, is we're actually gonna have CEUs available for therapists.
Ooh, yay. So it'll be a little more expensive for those but we partnered with another organization to be able to offer those. I love that ... people are like, "If only I could get CEUs for s- theology and spirituality and mental health." Oh, my gosh, yes. Now you can. You've just provided the answer to all of our quibbles.
That's right. I think we're... I think it's- ... 14 hours if you would like, oh, nice. That's not a ton, but. That's a significant amount. I don't know if I knew that. Yeah. But that's still- Yeah ... really good. Yeah ... so where can... if people haven't heard from you, where can they find out more? I'm also gonna link the the summit in the notes.
But if people wanted to follow up and just hear more from you and your wife and the work you're doing. Yeah. We are we're leading the Center for Embodied Faith. You can find that at embodiedfaith.life, is our website. Embodiedfaith.life. That's where you can find out about the summit. You can get links to our podcast, some of my Substack stuff, so you can find everything there.
Nice. And I'd like to ask one last question because this podcast is Here, Not There: Finding Our Way Back to Presence, Connection and Delight. So what has been bringing you a lot of delight lately? I love hearing the different stories. Oh. West Michigan in the summer is quite delightful. So right now- we're recording this in kinda mid-September, so it's starting to... fall's great. Getting chilly. But, Yeah ... the summer is ni- I was just sitting in the porch. It was getting chilly, and I was like, "Oh, there's no more lightning- ... lightning bugs," oh, no. Fireflies. It's kind of- Yes ... regional, so depending on where people are from.
So I grew up- Yeah ... calling them fireflies, and I was like, "Oh, they're not coming up- So did I ... anymore." Yes. Yeah ... s- yeah. So I, if... That last word I love in the podcast is delight. I think- Yeah ... delight is so important. So yeah, the fireflies in the dark evenings- ... brings me a lot of delight. That's beautiful.
Thank you for coming on, and hopefully this will also be airing on your podcast. People can kinda find out more. And yeah, listeners we'll see you next time.
I'm so glad you are here with me today. If this episode encouraged you, take a moment to follow, share, and like it on Facebook. That's how this space keeps growing. And may the God of presence, connection, and delight find you today in the little mercies along the way